|Year : 2021 | Volume
| Issue : 3 | Page : 546-549
Comparative yield of pulmonary tuberculosis by different symptoms among Saharia tribe of Madhya Pradesh, India
Ravendra Sharma1, VG Rao2, Rajiv Yadav2, Prashant Mishra2, Mercy Aparna Lingla2, Samridhi Nigam2, Jyothi Bhat2
1 ICMR-National Institute of Medical Statistics, New Delhi, India
2 Division of Communicable Diseases, ICMR-National Institute of Research in Tribal Health, Jabalpur, India
|Date of Submission||21-Jan-2018|
|Date of Acceptance||05-Jul-2021|
|Date of Web Publication||13-Oct-2021|
Dr. Jyothi Bhat
ICMR-National Institute of Research in Tribal Health, PO Garha, Nagpur Road, Jabalpur - 482 003, Madhya Pradesh
Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None
| Abstract|| |
Background: Symptom elicitation is a simple and inexpensive screening tool used for population screening in tuberculosis (TB) prevalence surveys. However, the information on the yield of TB cases by symptoms is sparsely available. Methods: A cross-sectional pulmonary TB (PTB) prevalence survey was conducted. All available eligible individuals were interviewed for symptoms of PTB. Sputum samples were collected and tested for PTB by smear microscopy and culture. Results: Among 2890 individuals tested for PTB, 77% had cough for 2 weeks or more and one-third reported chest pain for 1 month or more. About 31% were having a history of anti-TB treatment. Cough contributed to 82% PTB cases and the history of anti-TB treatment contributed to another 8.4% confirmed cases. Fever recorded lowest yield among the symptoms of PTB. Conclusion: The study suggests that fever alone may be ignored from symptomatic elicitation, and history of previous anti-TB treatment should be treated as an important indication for PTB symptomatic elicitation.
Keywords: India, pulmonary tuberculosis, Saharia tribe, symptoms, yield of tuberculosis
|How to cite this article:|
Sharma R, Rao V G, Yadav R, Mishra P, Lingla MA, Nigam S, Bhat J. Comparative yield of pulmonary tuberculosis by different symptoms among Saharia tribe of Madhya Pradesh, India. Indian J Community Med 2021;46:546-9
|How to cite this URL:|
Sharma R, Rao V G, Yadav R, Mishra P, Lingla MA, Nigam S, Bhat J. Comparative yield of pulmonary tuberculosis by different symptoms among Saharia tribe of Madhya Pradesh, India. Indian J Community Med [serial online] 2021 [cited 2021 Nov 27];46:546-9. Available from: https://www.ijcm.org.in/text.asp?2021/46/3/546/328171
| Introduction|| |
Tuberculosis (TB) is a serious public health challenge in India and it alone contributes about 27% of global TB cases and drug-resistant TB. There is wide geographical variation in the TB epidemic and its trends within the country. The Madhya Pradesh state contributes about 7% of India's total TB cases, and within the state, it remains predominantly a disease of the disadvantaged and marginalized social groups. Saharia tribe of Madhya Pradesh has the highest TB prevalence in the country with the reported prevalence rates of 1518 in 2008 and 3294 in 2012–13/100,000 population. In view of this, the ICMR-NIRTH in collaboration with the Government to Madhya Pradesh has taken up an “Intensified Tuberculosis Control among Saharia Tribe of Madhya Pradesh,” a project to reduce TB burden through active case detection and compliance to treatment involving the local village level volunteers. The study is currently being carried out in all Saharia dominated villages of seven districts in Madhya Pradesh. The present study presents the finding from the survey conducted as a baseline TB disease prevalence survey in these seven districts. The TB disease prevalence survey was carried out using the symptom elicitation screening tool, and the present study provides information on the yield of PTB cases by the various symptoms.
| Methods|| |
Madhya Pradesh state has the highest tribal population, and about one-fifth of the state population is classified as scheduled tribe. The Saharia, a Particularly Vulnerable Tribal Group (PVTG), is residing mainly in seven districts of Gwalior and Chambal division, i.e., Morena, Sheopur, Bhind, Gwalior, Datia, Shivpuri, and Ashok Nagar districts. A cross-sectional TB prevalence survey was carried out during January–May 2019 in selected villages from seven districts. The villages were selected in proportion to total Saharia population in the district. Overall, all available eligible (≥15 years) individuals were interviewed by the trained field investigators for symptoms of pulmonary TB (PTB), namely cough for 2 weeks or more, chest pain for 1 month or more, fever for 1 month or more, hemoptysis during the past 6 months, and persons with a history of previous anti-TB treatment. The individual with any one of the above symptoms was considered eligible for sputum collection. Two sputum samples were collected from all symptomatic individuals and tested for PTB by smear microscopy and culture.
The study was approved by the Institutional Ethical Committee (IEC) of ICMR – NIRTH, Jabalpur, (NIRTH/IEC/2273/2016). A written informed consent was obtained from all study participants.
| Results|| |
In the baseline survey, 20,114 individuals were screened for symptoms of PTB, and among them, 3001 (14.9%) individuals reported at least one PTB symptom and considered as presumptive PTB cases. The sputum could be collected from 2890 (96.3%) presumptive cases, and among these, 273 were found to be bacteriologically positive for PTB.
Association of symptoms with pulmonary tuberculosis
Among 2890 individuals tested for pulmonary TB, about 77% had cough for 2 weeks or more and one-third reported chest pain for 1 month or more. About 7% and 16% reported, respectively, to had experienced fever for 1 month or more and hemoptysis during the past 6 months. About 31% were also having a history of anti-TB treatment [Table 1]. The PTB positivity by symptoms was the highest (17.5%) among those who reported fever for 1 month or more compared to those who did not experience fever for 1 month (9%) (odds ratio [OR]=2.20; 95% confidence interval [CI]: 1.50–3.18; P < 0.001). Similarly, about 12% individuals with chest pain for 1 month or more were positive for PTB (OR = 1.65; 95% CI: 1.28–2.13; P < 0.001) compared to about 8% who did not have fever for 1 month or more. Significantly more individuals (12%) who had a history of anti-TB treatment were found to be positive for PTB (OR = 1.50; 95% CI: 1.56–1.93; P < 0.01) compared to those who did not have any anti-TB treatment history. Although more than three-fourth individuals tested for PTB reported cough for 2 weeks or more, only 10% were positive to PTB compared to 8% among those who did not report cough for 2 weeks or more as symptom. Similarly, the positivity was higher among those who experienced hemoptysis during the past 6 months (12%) compared to their respective counterparts (9%), but these differences were not statistically significant (P > 0.05).
|Table 1: Positivity by the common symptoms of pulmonary tuberculosis (n=2890)|
Click here to view
Yield of pulmonary tuberculosis by the symptoms
The yield of TB by different symptoms studied in sequential order of commonly documented symptoms of PTB. The cough (with or without any other symptoms) for 2 weeks or more was reported about 77% presumptive cases whose samples were tested but about 82% of bacteriologically confirmed PTB cases (224/273) were having cough. The chest pain (without cough) for 1 month or more contributed to 5.5% of presumptive and confirmed PTB cases.
In respect of combinations of symptoms, the distribution of symptomatic showed that among total symptomatic about 27% had both cough and chest pain, 18% had cough and history of anti-TB treatment, and 10% had cough and hemoptysis. Rest all TB symptoms contributed to <10% of symptomatic [Table 2]. Similarly, among 273 patients, about 38% had cough and chest pain, 30% had cough and history of anti-TB treatment, and 16% patients had cough and hemoptysis, and chest pain and history of anti-TB treatment symptoms of TB at the time of screening. About 14% patients were also having cough and fever symptoms and rest all other combinations contributed to less than 10% of total patients. Only 41 and 69 symptomatic and 11 and 20 patients, respectively, had symptoms of fever and hemoptysis and fever and history of anti-TB treatment. However, these combinations had the highest positivity, i.e., 29% (20/69) and 26.8% (11/41), respectively, among all combinations. The overall positivity was 9.4% (273/2890), but the combination of two symptoms increased the positivity and positivity increased more than two times in combinations of symptoms – cough and fever (19.9%), chest pain and fever (21.7%), fever and hemoptysis (26.8%), and fever and history of anti-TB treatment (29.0%).
|Table 2: Distribution of symptomatic, tuberculosis patients and positivity by combinations of symptoms|
Click here to view
However, the yield of individual symptoms in the TB patients is presented in [Table 3].
|Table 3: Yield of pulmonary tuberculosis by individual symptoms (n=2890)|
Click here to view
[TAG:2]Discussion & Conclusion [/TAG:2]
TB has been documented as a public health problem in the Saharia PVTG of Madhya Pradesh with alarmingly high prevalence of PTB. Although a decline in the prevalence has been documented in an intervention study, the prevalence of PTB remains exceptionally high even after the intervention. The recently carried out baseline survey in this community recorded the prevalence of PTB as 1357/100,000 population.
All these studies were carried out using the symptom elicitation screening tool. The chest X-ray, another screening tool, could not be used in all these surveys because of unavailability of mobile X-ray units. The cost of X-ray films and their processing and requirement of two qualified independent readers also restricted the use of chest X-rays in large surveys. Hence, the observed prevalence may be underestimation of the true prevalence in these studies, as the symptom screening alone could pick up about two-thirds of the cases only. It indicates that substantial numbers of cases may remain undetected if the solo use of symptom elicitation screening tool is used in TB surveys.
In the present study, only symptom elicitation screening tool was used to detect the symptomatic/presumptive PTB cases. The findings of the present study show the predominance of cough among all program endorsed symptoms of PTB. About 77% of total symptomatic and 88% of confirmed TB cases were having cough (with or without any other symptoms). Almost similar findings have also reported in the other surveys that used symptoms elicitation as a screening tool in the population.,, The chest pain has appeared as the second most important symptom of PTB, the chest pain (without cough) yielded about 5% of both – total symptomatic individuals and PTB cases. The hemoptysis during the past 6 months (without cough, chest pain, and fever) contributed about 5.4% symptomatic individuals and 3.7% total PTB cases. The elicitation of previous history during screening of population for symptoms of PTB contributes considerably to symptomatic individuals and PTB cases. The previous history of anti-TB (without cough, chest pain, fever, and hemoptysis) yielded 11% of symptomatic individuals and 8% PTB cases. The yield of previous history of anti-TB is relatively higher in Saharia tribe compared to other studies carried out in Madhya Pradesh, 3.6% in year 2008 and 5.9% in 2010. The greater yield of previous anti-TB treatment among Saharia tribe may be because of very high prevalence of PTB in the community. The fever (without cough and chest pain) recorded lowest yield among the symptoms of PTB, i.e., only 14 symptomatic individuals and 1 PTB case. Similar kind of findings was also reported by earlier studies.,, However, these results need to be interpreted with caution as among symptomatic individuals having fever for 1 month or more (with/without any other symptoms) were significantly more likely to be positive for PTB (OR = 2.20; 95% CI: 1.50–3.18; P < 0.001) compared to individuals without fever (but having other symptoms). The cough, chest pain, hemoptysis, and history of anti-TB treatment contributed more than 99% of symptomatic individuals and PTB cases. Hence, fever for 1 month or more without any other symptoms of PTB may be unheeded in the future PTB disease surveys. Overall, the study established cough for 2 weeks or more as the most predominant symptom for screening of the population for the PTB prevalence surveys in the community. The findings of the study also suggest that the fever alone may be ignored from symptomatic elicitation in future studies, but the history of previous anti-TB treatment should be recorded with due care and treated as an important indication for PTB symptomatic elicitation.
Authors are grateful to Dr. Balram Bhargava, Secretary, Department of Health Research, MoHFW, and Director-General, ICMR for his support and encouragement. Authors also express their gratitude to the Principal Secretaries at Department of Health and Department of Tribal Welfare, Government of Madhya Pradesh, State TB Officer, Bhopal. Authors sincerely thank Dr. Aparup Das, Director, ICMR-National Institute of Research in Tribal Health, Jabalpur, for providing facilities to carry out the study. The support provided by districts' Chief Medical Officers and District TB Officers to the study is highly acknowledged by the authors. Authors also thank to all study participants for their cooperation and providing information on symptoms and sputum samples. We also thank our field, laboratory, data entry, and secretarial staff for their hard work.
The manuscript has been approved by the Publication Screening Committee of ICMR-NIRTH, Jabalpur and assigned with the number ICMR-NIRTH/PSC/34/2020.
Financial support and sponsorship
The study is financially supported by the Government of Madhya Pradesh (Budget 2210/2017-18/877 dated_27/01/18). However, the funding agency had no role in the study design, data collection, analyses, interpretation of results, reports and manuscript writing, and submission to the journal.
Conflicts of interest
There are no conflicts of interest.
| References|| |
Rao VG, Gopi PG, Bhat J, Selvakumar N, Yadav R, Tiwari B, et al.
Pulmonary tuberculosis: A public health problem amongst the Saharia, a primitive tribe of Madhya Pradesh, Central India. Int J Infect Dis 2010;14:e713-6.
Rao VG, Bhat J, Yadav R, Muniyandi M, Sharma R, Bhondeley MK. Pulmonary tuberculosis – A health problem amongst Saharia tribe in Madhya Pradesh. Indian J Med Res 2015;141:630-5.
] [Full text]
Bhat J, Sharma RK, Yadav R, Rao VG. The baseline TB disease prevalence survey under intensified tuberculosis control among Saharia tribe of Madhya Pradesh study. In: Un-Published Report. Jabalpur: ICMR-National Institute of Research in Tribal Health.
Rao VG, Bhat J, Yadav R, Sharma RK, Muniyandi M. Declining tuberculosis prevalence in Saharia, a particularly vulnerable tribal community in Central India: Evidences for action. BMC Infect Dis 2019;19:180.
Bhat J, Yadav R, Sharma RK, Muniyandi M, Rao VG. Tuberculosis elimination in India's Saharia group. Lancet Glob Health 2019;7:e1618.
Gopi PG, Subramani R, Sadacharam K, Narayanan PR. Yield of pulmonary tuberculosis cases by employing two screening methods in a community survey. Int J Tuberc Lung Dis 2006;10:343-5.
Rao VG, Bhat J, Yadav R, Gopi PG, Selvakumar N, Wares DF. Diagnosis of pulmonary tuberculosis by symptoms among tribals in central India. Natl Med J India 2010;23:372-3.
Rao VG, Bhat J, Yadav R, Muniyandi M, Bhondeley MK, Wares DF. Yield of pulmonary tuberculosis cases by symptoms: Findings from a community survey in Madhya Pradesh, central India. Indian J Tuberc 2015;62:121-3.
[Table 1], [Table 2], [Table 3]